B flat Instruments
Although the sharp keys are not so straightforward for young
clarinettists, schools have reported how well children respond to the challenge of these
opening carols.
Away in a Manger (page 5) is set out in two keys.
Non-specialist teachers may not realise that for B flat clarinettists to join in with
violins, recorders etc, the clarinet players should play their version in key A, while the
others play in key G. Alternatively of course, clarinets are in key G, while
the rest move down to key F. (Don't try all the Gs together!)
Most of the subsequent carols are in flat keys, so here the advantage
definitely lies with the B flat players.